Republicans define “elitism” with cultural signifiers: If you like latte, live on the coasts, eat organic food, drive a car made in northern Europe (Saab, Volvo, VW…) hunt birds rather than deer…etc.
Democrats, back in the days of Harry Truman and FDR, defined elitism in economic terms - “Malefactors of great wealth,” “economic royalists,” “the rich, lolling obscenely in opera boxes…” (actually, that was Mencken).
A reporter asked Sherrod Brown a couple years ago why so many rural and poor whites were voting for Republicans. His response: “Because Democrats stopped talking to them.”
A big piece of that has to do with the Civil and Voting Rights Acts, and their political aftermath. LBJ said that “we’ve lost the South for a generation” due to those Acts, but he lost more than the south: Racist whites everywhere were alienated from the Democratic Party. Part (at this point, only a small part, I hope) of the “elitist” charge is lingering resentment against urban northeastern Democrats for overturning the structures and privileges of Southern Post-Reconstruction society. The “outsiders” who tore down a system that had worked (for whites, anyway) for a hundred years were the original targets of the charge of elitism.
I am far to the left of most democrats these days because I’m an old-fashioned economic liberal - I’d love to see a far more progressive income tax, tilting the playing field in favor of union organizing, government regulation of public goods, single-payer health care, and so on.
Analysis and opinions concerning the issues of the day, from the point of view of a populist, New-Deal-style Democrat. You can reach me at mftalbot (at) hotmail dot com
Showing posts with label Liberals. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Liberals. Show all posts
Tuesday, September 02, 2008
Sunday, August 24, 2008
Whose side are you on?
Everything Walmart does is guided by one consideration: anything that competes with maximum profits for the owners is something they oppose.
Workers want a raise?
That's competition.
Struggling main-street sporting goods store that has sponsored the local little league team since the current coach's grandfather was a player?
Competition.
Government investigating you locking workers in the store and other abuse of your workers?
Competition.
Liberals, get this straight: Walmart is the anti-Christ. It's better to buy ersatz affection at a whorehouse than a genuine hairdryer at Walmart.
"Free Trade" is "There'll be a pay cut before we fire you and 'offshore' your job."
"The nation can't afford single-payer healthcare" is "We rich people don't want to pay for single-payer healthcare."
Got that?
Workers want a raise?
That's competition.
Struggling main-street sporting goods store that has sponsored the local little league team since the current coach's grandfather was a player?
Competition.
Government investigating you locking workers in the store and other abuse of your workers?
Competition.
Liberals, get this straight: Walmart is the anti-Christ. It's better to buy ersatz affection at a whorehouse than a genuine hairdryer at Walmart.
"Free Trade" is "There'll be a pay cut before we fire you and 'offshore' your job."
"The nation can't afford single-payer healthcare" is "We rich people don't want to pay for single-payer healthcare."
Got that?
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)